Corporal punishment in schools: Quick and dirty solution.
I had no idea that it was still OK to spank or otherwise discipline students physically (spanking and paddling) in the United States. Apparently in many states it is, including (surprise) Alabama, Oklahoma, Texas, Mississippi, and literally the whole South-Eastern United States where it is used quite frequently. Last year over 220,000 students received corporal punishment.
According to a report by CNN, African-American students are almost twice as likely to receive corporal punishment as are students with mental and physical disabilities.
CNN has a poll on their site that asks, “Should corporal punishment be banned in schools?” Surprisingly enough, the people who say that it shouldn’t be banned are winning 57% to 43%. Go vote yes!
Physical abuse doesn’t teach the child why what they did was wrong. More often then not, in my experience, it causes a child to be more rebellious and makes them fear authority instead of respect authority. In addition, many adults who administer physical abuse as punishment have difficulty controlling their own anger and end up taking it out on the child. It’s a dangerous way to discipline children. We need more counselors in these schools where they are hitting children.
I’m sure you won’t be surprised to hear that James Dobson, the douche-bag from Focus on the Family, is in favor of beating children in grade school, but believes it to be ineffective for high school students.
A parent in Alpine, Texas who approached the principal and superintendent of her child’s school where her son was beat said that administrators believe “most parents like this because it takes care of the punishment. It gets the kids back in class. It doesn’t disrupt instruction. It’s like the quick and dirty way of dealing with discipline problems.”
Not OK America.
(via CNN.com)
2 Comments so far ...
As a school guidance counselor I would like to agree and back up the research against corporal punishment in schools. I would also like to offer that the interpretation of “spare the rod, spoil the child” is frequently misinterpreted. A staff or rod was used to “guide” the flock, not beat it. Fear is rarely an effective teacher of respect. It horrifies me how easily I can identify the students that have suffered these abuses at home. It shows time and time again in other behaviors,including, yes, violence toward themselves and their peers. Thank you for comments.
Comment on August 20, 2008 10:18 amThanks for commenting. nice to get a professional opinion regarding it too. I agree!
Comment on August 20, 2008 10:22 am